OCR-D Network

1. Why do we need OCR-D Network?

After having processors running locally via the CLI, communication over network is the natural extension. The OCR-D Network package, which is implemented as part of OCR-D/core, allows users to set up OCR-D in a distributed environment. This setup greatly improves the flexibility, scalability and reliability of OCR-D.

2. Terminology

3. The Specification

When having OCR-D running over network, it should expose endpoints to allow users’ interactions. Those endpoints are described here. It follows the OpenAPI specification. Most endpoints are already included in OCR-D/core. The rest could be implemented by the organization which uses it. There are 4 parts in the specification: discovery, processing, workflow, and workspace.

Discovery: The service endpoints in this section provide information about the server. They include, but are not limited to, hardware configuration, installed processors, and information about each processor.

Processing: Via the service endpoints in this section, one can get information about a specific processor, trigger a processor run, and check the status of a running processor. By exposing these endpoints, the server can encapsulate the detailed setup of the system and offer users a single entry to the processors. The implementation of this section is provided by OCR-D/core.

Workflow: Beyond single processors, one can manage entire workflows, i.e. a series of connected processor instances. A workflow is a text file that describes the OCR-D workflow using ocrd process syntax.

Workspace: The service endpoints in this section concern data management, which in OCR-D is handled via workspaces. (A workspace is the combination of a METS file and any number of referenced files already downloaded, i.e. with locations relative to the METS file path.) Processing (via single processors or workflows) always refers to existing workspaces, i.e. workspaces residing in the server’s file system.

4. Suggested OCR-D System Architecture

This document presents two possible architecture setup using OCR-D Network and the technical details behind. In both setup, all servers are implemented using FastAPI. Behind the scene, it runs Uvicorn, an ASGI web server implementation for Python. RabbitMQ is used for the Process Queue, and MongoDB is the database system. There are many options for a reverse proxy, such as Nginx, Apache, or HAProxy. From our side, we recommend using Traefik.

4.1 Processors as workers

Distributed architecture where processors are deployed as workers.
Fig. 1: A distributed architecture with message queue. In this architecture, processors are deployed as workers.

As shown in Fig. 1, each section in the Web API specification is implemented by different servers, which are Discovery Server, Processing Server, Workflow Server, and Workspace Server respectively. Although each server in the figure is deployed on its own machine, it is completely up to the implementers to decide which machines run which servers. However, having each processor run on its own machine reduces the risk of version and resource conflicts. Furthermore, the machine can be customized to best fit the processor’s hardware requirements and throughput demand. For example, some processors need GPU computation, while others do not, or some need more CPU capacity while others need more memory.

Processing: once a request arrives, it will be pushed to a job queue. A job queue always has the same name as its respective processors. For example, ocrd-olena-binarizeprocessors listen only to the queue named ocrd-olena-binarize. A Processing Worker, which is an OCR-D Processor running as a worker, listens to the queue, pulls new jobs when available, processes them, and push the job statuses back to the queue if necessary. One normally does not run a Processing Worker directly, but via a Processing Server. Job statuses can be pushed back to the queue, depending on the job configuration, so that other services get updates and act accordingly.

Database: in this architecture, a database is required to store information such as users requests, jobs statuses, workspaces, etc. MongoDB is required here.

Network File System: in order to avoid file transfer between different machines, it is highly recommended to have a Network File System (NFS) set up. With NFS, all Processing Servers(specifically processors) can work in a shared storage environment and access files as if they are local files. To get data into the NFS, one could use the POST /workspace endpoint to upload OCRD-ZIPfiles. However, this approach is only appropriate for testing or very limited data sizes. Usually, Workspace Server should be able to pull data from other storage.

4.2 Processors as servers

Distributed architecture where processors are deployed as servers.
Fig. 2: A distributed architecture where processors are deployed as servers.

The difference between this architecture and the one shown in Fig. 1 is the processors. In this architecture, each processor runs as a server and exposes one endpoint. When the Processing Server receives a request, it will forward that request to the respective Processor Server and wait for the response.

This architecture is simpler than the other one, since there is no need to have a Process Queue involved. Without a queue, all communications are synchronous. It means that clients need to wait for responses from Processing Server. It might take a long time, therefore high timeout is recommended.

5. Usage

Both setups above can be used as follows:

  1. Retrieve information about the system via endpoints in the Discovery section.
  2. Create a workspace (from an OCRD-ZIP or METS URL) via the POST /workspace endpoint and get back a workspace ID.
  3. Create a workflow by uploading a workflow script to the system via the POST /workflow endpoint and get back a workflow ID.
  4. One can either:
    • Trigger a single processor on a workspace by calling the POST /processor/run/{executable} endpoint with the chosen processor name, workspace ID and parameters, or
    • Start a workflow on a workspace by calling the POST /workflow/run endpoint with the chosen workflow ID and workspace ID.
    • In both cases, a job ID is returned.
  5. With the given job ID, it is possible to check the job status by calling:
    • GET /processor/job/{job-id} for a single processor, or
    • GET /workflow/job/{job-id} for the workflow.
  6. Download the resulting workspace via the GET /workspace/{workspace-id} endpoint and get back an OCRD-ZIP. Set the request header to Accept: application/json in case you only want the meta-data of the workspace but not the files.

6. Technical Details

6.1 How does Processing Server process requests?

As one can see from two setups above, the Processing Server needs to go through many steps when it receives a request. These steps are illustrated in Fig. 3 below.

This activity diagram shows how a Processing Server handles a request
Fig. 3: This activity diagram shows how a Processing Server handles a request.

Job cache: there are usually dependencies between jobs, i.e. one job can only run after other jobs are finished. To support this, when the Processing Server receives a job at /processor/run/{processor-name} endpoint, it first checks if all dependent jobs are finished or not. If not, the new coming job will be cached and then executed later.

Page lock: to avoid conflict, only one job is allowed to write to a page group at a time. Therefore, before a job is executed, its output file group is locked so that other jobs cannot write to it. The group will then be unlocked when the job finished. If a job needs to write to a locked file group, it will be cached and executed later.

6.2 Processing Server

A Processing Server is a server which exposes REST endpoints in the Processing section of the Web API specification. In the queue-based system architecture, a Processing Server is responsible for deployment management and enqueuing workflow jobs. For the former, a Processing Server can deploy, re-use, and shutdown Processing Workers, Process Queue, and Database, depending on the configuration. For the latter, it decodes requests and delegates them to the Process Queue. Additionally, it is possible to start the needed components externally, with Docker. Therefore skip_deployment: true can be set in the process_queue and database section of the configuration file.

To start a Processing Server, run

$ ocrd network processing-server --address=<IP>:<PORT> /path/to/config.yml

This command starts a Processing Server on the provided IP address and port. It accepts only one argument, which is the path to a configuration file. The schema of a configuration file can be found here. Below is a small example of how the file might look like.

  address: localhost
  port: 5672
    username: admin
    password: admin
    username: cloud
    path_to_privkey: /path/to/file
  address: localhost
  port: 27017
    username: admin
    password: admin
    username: cloud
    password: "1234"
  - address: localhost
    username: cloud
    password: "1234"
      - name: ocrd-cis-ocropy-binarize
        number_of_instance: 2
        deploy_type: native
      - name: ocrd-olena-binarize
        number_of_instance: 1
        deploy_type: docker

  - address:
    username: tdoan
    path_to_privkey: /path/to/file
      - name: ocrd-eynollah-segment
        number_of_instance: 1
        deploy_type: native

There are three main sections in the configuration file.

  1. process_queue: it contains the address and port, where the Process Queue is deployed, or will be deployed with the specified credentials. If the ssh property is presented, the Processing Server will try to connect to the address via ssh with provided username and password and deploy RabbitMQ at the specified port. The remote machine must have Docker installed since the deployment is done via Docker. Make sure that the provided username has enough rights to run Docker commands. In case the ssh property is not presented, the Processing Server assumes that RabbitMQ was already deployed and just uses it.
  2. database: this section also contains the address and port, where the MongoDB is running, or will run. If credentials is presented, it will be used when deploying and connecting to the database. The ssh section behaves exactly the same as described in the process_queue section above.
  3. hosts: this section contains a list of hosts, usually virtual machines, where Processing Workers should be deployed. To be able to connect to a host, an address and username are required, then comes either password or path_to_privkey (path to a private key). All Processing Workers, which should be deployed, must be declared under the workers property. In case deploy_type is docker, make sure that Docker is installed in the target machine and the provided username has enough rights to execute Docker commands.

Among three sections, process_queue and database are required, hosts is optional. Processing Workers can additionally be start externally and register themselves to the process_queue`. For more information, please check the configuration file schema.

6.3 Process Queue

By using a queuing system for individual per-workspace per-job processor runs, specifically as message queuing with RabbitMQ, the reliability and flexibility of the Processing Server are greatly improved over a system directly coupling the workflow engine and distributed processor instances.

In our implementation of the Process Queue, manual acknowledgment mode is used. This means, when a Processing Worker finishes successfully, it sends a positive ACK signal to RabbitMQ. In case of failure, it tries again three times before sending a negative ACK signal. When a negative signal is received, RabbitMQ will re-queue the message. If there is not any ACK signal sent for any reason (e.g. consumer crash, power outage, network problem, etc.), RabbitMQ will automatically re-queue the message after timeout, which is 30 minutes by default. This behavior, however, can be overridden by setting another value for the consumer_timeout property in the rabbitmq.conf file.

To avoid processing the same input twice (in case of re-queuing), a Processing Worker first checks the redeliver property to see if this message was re-queued. If yes, and the status of this process in the database is not SUCCESS, it will process the data described in the message again.

When a Processing Server receives a request, it creates a message based on the request content, then push it to a job queue. A job queue always has the same name as its respective processors. For example, ocrd-olena-binarize processors listen only to the job queue named ocrd-olena-binarize. Below is an example of how a message looks like. For a detailed schema, please check the message schema.

job_id: uuid
processor_name: ocrd-cis-ocropy-binarize

path_to_mets: /path/to/mets.xml
page_id: PHYS_001,PHYS_002
  params_1: 1
  params_2: 2

result_queue_name: ocrd-cis-ocropy-binarize-result
callback_url: https://my.domain.com/callback
internall_callback_url: http://ocrd-processing-server:8000

created_time: 1668782988590

In the message content, job_id, processor_name, internal_callback_url and created_time are added by the Processing Server, while the rest comes from the body of the POST /processor/run/{executable} request.

Instead of path_to_mets, one can also use workspace_id to specify a workspace. An ID of a workspace can be obtained from the Workspace Server which is not part of OCR-D core.

In case result_queue_name property is present, the result of the processing will be pushed to the queue with the provided name. If the queue does not exist yet, it will be created on the fly. This is useful when there is another service waiting for the results of processing. That service can simply listen to that queue and will be immediately notified when the results are available. Below is a simple Python script to demonstrate how a service can listen to the result_queue_name and act accordingly.

import pika, sys, os

def main():
    credentials = pika.PlainCredentials('username', 'password')
    connection = pika.BlockingConnection(pika.ConnectionParameters(host='my.domain.name', port=5672, credentials=credentials))
    channel = connection.channel()

    # Create the result queue, in case it does not exist yet
    result_queue_name = 'ocrd-cis-ocropy-binarize-result'

    def callback(ch, method, properties, body):
        print(' [x] Received %r' % body)

    channel.basic_consume(queue=result_queue_name, on_message_callback=callback, auto_ack=True)

    print(' [*] Waiting for job results.)

It is important that the result queue exists before one starts listening on it, otherwise an error is thrown. The best way to ensure this is trying to create the result queue in the listener service, as shown in the Python script above. In RabbitMQ, this action is idempotent, which means that the creation only happens if the queue doesn’t exist yet, otherwise nothing will happen. For more information, please check the RabbitMQ tutorials.

If the callback_url in the processing message is set, a POST request will be made to the provided endpoint when the processing is finished. The body of the request is the result message described below.

The schema for result messages can be found here. This message is sent to the callback URL or to the result queue, depending on the configuration in the processing message. An example of the message looks like this:

job_id: uuid
status: SUCCESS
path_to_mets: /path/to/mets.xml

With the returned job_id, one can retrieve more information by sending a GET request to the /processor/job/{job_id} endpoint, or to /processor/log/{job_id} to get all logs of that job.

6.4 Processing Worker

A Processing Worker can be started manually, or it can be managed by a Processing Server via a configuration file. There are the two ways to start a processing worker:

# 1. Use processor name
$ <processor-name> worker --queue=<queue-address> --database=<database-address>

# 2. Use ocrd CLI bundled with OCR-D/core
$ ocrd network processing-worker <processor-name> --queue=<queue-address> --database=<database-address>

6.5 Processor Server

Same as Processing Worker, there are also two ways to start a Processor Server:

# 1. Use processor name
$ <processor-name> server --address=<server-address> --database=<database-address>

# 2. Use ocrd CLI bundled with OCR-D/core
$ ocrd network processor-server <processor-name> --queue=<queue-address> --database=<database-address>

6.6 Database

A database is required to store necessary information such as users requests, jobs statuses, workspaces, etc. MongoDB is used in this case. To connect to MongoDB via a Graphical User Interface, MongoDB Compass is recommended.